All Calories are Not Created Equal



Share This Post

Calorie counting sucks and I’ve never asked any of my clients to do it. “Calories in, calories out” just doesn’t work for everyone. There are a multitude of reasons why it’s not this simple, and here are just a few reasons, with insight into how our amazing bodies utilise calories differently on a daily basis.

Thermic Effect of Food

  • Thermogenesis is a term used to describe the energy (calories) lost through the production of heat in tissues such as adipose (fat) tissue and skeletal muscle.
  • Certain foods and macronutrients produce more heat after consumption than others, therefore burning through more calories at rest.
  • Dietary fat such as nuts, oils and avocados produce 0-3% thermogenesis, dietary carbohydrates such as rice, vegetables, pasta, and bread produce 5-10% thermogenesis, and protein-rich foods such as lean meats, legumes, and eggs produce 20-30% thermogenesis!
  • This demonstrates a calorie of protein compared to a calorie of carbohydrates is going to produce a larger thermic effect and expend more energy per mouthful.

Resting Metabolic Rate

Following my first point, each individual has a different resting metabolic rate that is influenced by factors such as age, gender, muscle-to-fat ratio, amount of physical activity and hormone function. Resting metabolic rate (RMR) is the energy that you burn at rest/whilst sedentary.

  • For example, individuals who engage in regular weight training have increased lean muscle mass and decreased free fat mass, therefore burning an additional 12-13% at rest due to these variables.
  • This means that if you consumed 2,800 calories in a day, 2,296 of those would be burnt at rest, compared to your sedentary counterpart burning 1,960 at rest!

Fibre Content

  • Fibre is the indigestible part of plant foods, such as vegetables, fruits, grains, nuts, seeds and legumes.
  • Our bodies can only absorb nutrients when they come into physical contact with our intestinal walls, and because fibre is not absorbed, it acts as a carrier to dilute and eliminate calories in our faeces.
  • Fibre dilutes calories by expanding the volume of food, fills our stomach through absorbing fluid, and delays stomach emptying through creating a gel that keeps you fuller for longer.
  • Studies on the consumption of whole-grain bread versus white bread on stool analysis show that individuals flush nearly more than twice as many calories when consuming the fibre-rich whole-grain bread!
  • This shows that it’s not the calories you eat, but the calories you absorb!!

Glycaemic Index & Glycaemic Load

  • The glycaemic index (GI) represents the rise in blood sugar levels two hours after consuming a particular food, and glycaemic load (GL) is an extension of this which additionally considers the carbohydrate quantity/content of a particular food.
  • A rise in blood sugar after consuming a high GL food product such as sugar-sweetened breakfast cereals or white bread triggers the release of insulin which influences how calories/energy are utilised and can potentially store excess energy as adipose (fat) tissue.
  • This means a calorie from a higher GL food, in comparison to a calorie from a lower GL food such as non-starchy vegetables and/or whole grains, can increase fat storage in your body.

I hope this has given you some insight as to why calorie counting is an over simplified method for weight control and why it doesn’t always work.

Want to know how I help my clients to control their weight? Head on over to my Metabolic Balance page for all of the details.

Ask Jayne Mossop any questions about getting healthy - Book a Call

Book a FREE 15 Minute Discovery Call

Want to have a chat about what's going on for you and how I might be able to support you make some changes?

More To Explore

Stressed business woman with headache, rubbing her temples

Impact of Stress on Weight Management

Stress is Messing With Your Health When you are dealing with stressful situations either at work or home, have you noticed excess weight can start


How a Clinical Nutritionist Can Help You

Usually reaching out and seeking help from a Clinical Nutritionist can coincide with recognising or wanting diet-based change in your life. This can range from

Stress Management Tips

Is stress taking over your life? Download my free Stress Management Tips now to start taking things down a few pegs.

Subscribe for help and advice on healthy eating and lifestyle updates. Unsubscribe with 1 click at any time.

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe. Here’s our privacy policy


Jayne Mossop
Corporate Wellness Programs

Jayne delivers her wellness presentations in a relatable, friendly style and aims to bust the current food myths to provide her audience with practical “take-home” tips that can be easily integrated into individual lifestyles.

Enter your email below to download
Jayne’s program information guide 

Receive the latest nutrition news

Subscribe to our newsletter and get our bonus guide to a healthy balanced meal

Subscribe for help and advice on healthy eating and lifestyle updates.

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe.
Here’s our privacy policy

Get our bonus guide to a healthy balanced meal

Hope you enjoy this guide, it’s straight out of my 12 WEEKS to FEEL LIKE YOU AGAIN program and I know if you follow it, you’re going to love it!

Subscribe for help and advice on healthy eating and lifestyle updates, starting with this Ultimate Guide to Portion Control. Unsubscribe with 1 click at any time.

We hate SPAM and promise to keep your email address safe.
Here’s our privacy policy